Best Peanut Butter by PureScore

Peanut butter is a short shopping list, and the jars still do not land on the same PureScore. This ranking uses the published PureScore already on each product page. The live composite is ingredient safety (40%), formulation quality (30%), contaminant risk (20%), and label transparency (10%). Labels that are only partly matched stay off the list.

Ranked peanut butter

Rank	Product	Brand	PureScore	Label begins	Buy
1	Yumbutter, organic peanut butter with cayenne, turmeric & cumin	Yumbutter	90	Organic peanuts, organic cumin, organic turmeric, organic cayenne pepper, organic garlic, sea salt	Buy
2	Creamy Dark Roast Peanut Butter	Santa Cruz Organic	88	ORGANIC ROASTED PEANUTS, ORGANIC PALM OIL, CONTAINS 1% OR LESS OF SALT	Buy
3	Peanut Butter with Honey	Trader Joe's	88	Dry roasted peanuts, organic honey, sea salt	Buy
4	Peanut Butter Spread	Skippy	86	roasted peanuts, palm oil, salt	Buy
5	PEANUT BUTTER SPREAD	Jif	86	peanuts, palm oil, salt	Buy
6	Peanut Butter Schmier	Jack&Amos	55	Roasted peanuts, sugar, partially hydrogenated vegetable oils, (cottonseed, rapeseed and soybean)	Buy

Yumbutter, organic peanut butter with cayenne, turmeric & cumin at 90 is Excellent. Its label begins: Organic peanuts, organic cumin, organic turmeric, organic cayenne pepper, organic garlic, sea salt. Jack&Amos Peanut Butter Schmier at 55 is Fair. Its label begins: Roasted peanuts, sugar, partially hydrogenated vegetable oils, (cottonseed, rapeseed and soybean).

Open a product page before you buy. Search the catalog for peanut butter. The same model is written up on the methodology page. The published sweeteners and spreads Top 10 covers the wider sweeteners and spreads aisle.

Disclosure

As an Amazon Associate, Label Matter earns from qualifying purchases. PureScores come from Label Matter's ingredient model and catalog data; they are not paid placements and are not medical, dietary, or nutritional advice. Scores can change when labels or data update.